Publication: ἜΛΕΓΧΟΣ en la Retórica a Alejandro: ¿Prueba o refutación?
Loading...
Identifiers
Publication date
2014
Defense date
Authors
Advisors
Tutors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidad Carlos III de Madrid
Impact
Export
Abstract
Generalmente, ἔλεγχος significa, tanto en contexto filosófico como en contexto oratorio, el
argumento refutativo. Contra la elección de, por ejemplo, Chiron, que prefiere un genérico 'preuve' en su
reciente traducción francesa, en las siguientes páginas defendemos que aquel sentido es más adecuado en la
exposición sobre los medios de persuasión de la Retórica a Alejandro. Para ello aludiremos a las semejanzas
reseñables que presenta el capítulo dedicado al ἔλεγχος en la Retórica a Alejandro con algunos textos
aristotélicos, semejanzas que permiten hablar de una más que probable inspiración a partir de las doctrinas
lógicas aristotélicas y, en concreto, a partir de su doctrina dialéctica del ἔλεγχος como argumento refutativo.
The greek term ἔλεγχος means generally, both in philosophical and oratorical contexts, the refutative argument. Against, for instance, Chiron, who prefers a generic term as 'preuve' in his recent French translation of the Rhetrorica ad Alexandrum, in the following pages we will argue, on the contrary, 'refutation' as a more accurate translation of the term. In order to give support to our thesis, we will show some significant similarities between the chapter devoted to the ἔλεγχος in the Rhetorica ad Alexandrum and some aristotelian texts, which suggest that the former has been very probably inspired by Aristotle's logical doctrines and particularly by his dialectical conception of the ἔλεγχος as a refutative argument
The greek term ἔλεγχος means generally, both in philosophical and oratorical contexts, the refutative argument. Against, for instance, Chiron, who prefers a generic term as 'preuve' in his recent French translation of the Rhetrorica ad Alexandrum, in the following pages we will argue, on the contrary, 'refutation' as a more accurate translation of the term. In order to give support to our thesis, we will show some significant similarities between the chapter devoted to the ἔλεγχος in the Rhetorica ad Alexandrum and some aristotelian texts, which suggest that the former has been very probably inspired by Aristotle's logical doctrines and particularly by his dialectical conception of the ἔλεγχος as a refutative argument
Description
Congreso Internacional celebrado en la Universidad Carlos III de Madrid del 24 al 26 de septiembre de 2012
Keywords
Proof, Dialectic, Rhetoric, Refutación, Prueba, Dialéctica, Retórica, Refutation
Bibliographic citation
Pensar la traducción: la filosofía de camino entre las lenguas. Actas del Congreso (Talleres de comunicaciones). Madrid, septiembre de 2012. Madrid: Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, 2014. Pp. 60-72